GristleHub

Reviewing the gristliest restaurants
the midwest has to offer.

Pink Ivy

View on Google Maps

Walking into Pink Ivy felt like stepping into a curated dream—emerald booths, pink chairs, and a floral mural that whispered stories of resilience and beauty. The ambiance spoke volumes, reminding me of family gatherings where every detail mattered. The roasted delicata squash, with its crunchy skin and caracara orange, transported me back to my aunt's kitchen, where flavors were layered with love and history. Each bite was a testament to the idea that food can be both a comfort and a revelation.

Absolutely, Lisa. The decor was a visual feast, but the real star was the menu. The braised lamb toast, paired with lemon ricotta and pomegranate, was a harmonious blend of textures and flavors. It reminded me of the fusion dishes my grandmother used to make, where tradition met innovation. The staff's warmth added to the experience, making it feel less like dining out and more like coming home.

I felt that too. The chicken-bacon meatballs in shawarma cream sauce were a delightful surprise, echoing the street food stalls of my childhood. It was a dish that spoke of journeys—both personal and culinary. The portions were modest, but each plate was crafted with intention, inviting us to savor and reflect.​

Exactly. The pineapple brown butter cake for dessert was a nostalgic nod to the sweets of my youth, yet elevated with a modern twist. It encapsulated the essence of Pink Ivy—a place where memories are honored and new ones are created. It's a restaurant that doesn't just serve food; it tells stories.​

While Pink Ivy's ambiance and innovative dishes left a lasting impression, there were aspects that didn't resonate as well. The portion sizes, for instance, felt modest, especially given the price point. The chicken-bacon meatballs, though flavorful, left me wishing for a bit more substance on the plate. Additionally, the service, while friendly, seemed a touch overwhelmed during peak hours, leading to longer wait times between courses. It's a reminder that even in spaces that feel like home, there's always room for growth.​

I hear you, Lisa. The pricing did seem a bit steep for some dishes, particularly when the portions didn't quite match expectations. The burger, while delicious with its soy-braised onions and special sauce, felt more like a gourmet slider than a full meal. And while I appreciate a curated menu, a few more options, especially for those with dietary restrictions, would enhance the dining experience. Still, the creativity and passion behind each dish are evident, and I believe with a few tweaks, Pink Ivy can truly shine.​

For me, Pink Ivy earns a 7.5 out of 10. The ambiance and innovative dishes, like the roasted delicata squash, were memorable and evoked personal nostalgia. However, the modest portion sizes and occasional service delays during peak hours slightly detracted from the overall experience.

I'd rate it an 8 out of 10. The fusion of flavors in dishes like the braised lamb toast showcased culinary creativity, and the staff's warmth added to the welcoming atmosphere. While the pricing felt a bit steep for some items, the quality and presentation made it worthwhile.

Overall, Pink Ivy offers a delightful dining experience with room for minor improvements.​